Sheep or Goats: Which Fits Your Pasture?
Match the animal to the ground
MARFA, Texas — Choose sheep if you have grass and want a grazer, and choose goats if you have brush and want a browser. That's the short version. Sheep prefer grasses and clovers close to the ground, while goats like to pick leaves, shrubs, and woody plants at head height. Fencing, markets, parasite pressure, and your own temperament matter too, so it pays to look past the cute pictures.
Both are small ruminants, both are a manageable size, and both can fit a small farm. They are not interchangeable.
Look at what's growing on your land
Walk the pasture and list what you see. Mostly grass and legumes with few weeds suits sheep. A mix of brush, vines, multiflora rose, and broadleaf weeds suits goats. Many producers run both for that reason: goats clean up what sheep ignore. Check with your extension office or ATTRA, which publishes guides on small ruminant production, to match species to forage. A soil map from Web Soil Survey can also tell you about the ground itself.
Know your toxic plants. Both species can be poisoned by some plants, and hungry animals eat what they'd normally skip.
Fencing and shelter are different
Goats test fences. A fence that holds sheep may not hold goats, which climb, lean, and squeeze. Woven wire, good corner posts, and electric offsets help. Sheep generally respect fences more, though predators don't. Both need protection from dogs, coyotes, and other predators, and many producers use guardian animals, tight fencing, or night penning.
Shelter needs differ too. Goats dislike rain and wet feet more than sheep do, and they need dry, draft-free shelter. Sheep carry wool and handle cold better but suffer in wet, muddy conditions. Plan for both.
Compare the markets
Sheep produce lamb, wool, and sometimes milk. Goats produce meat, milk, and fiber depending on breed. Markets differ by region and by season, and demand can be tied to cultural and religious holidays, so you need to find your local buyers before you buy animals. Check AgMRC for market information and USDA market news for current reports. The American Sheep Industry Association has industry information for sheep producers.
Look at current prices yourself, from current reports, and call buyers and sale barns in your area. Prices move.
Parasites and health: the part that surprises beginners
Internal parasites, especially barber pole worm, are a major problem for both species in warm, wet climates, and goats are particularly susceptible. Resistance to dewormers is widespread. Learn the basics early. The WormX site offers information on managing parasites and resistance in small ruminants. Ask a vet familiar with small ruminants about vaccines, hoof care, and mineral needs. A mineral formulated for sheep can be toxic to sheep if it has the wrong copper level, so don't assume sheep and goats can share feed.
Time and labor
Both need regular checks, hoof trimming, and attention at lambing or kidding. Dairy goats need daily milking. Sheep may need shearing at least yearly, depending on the breed, and shearers can be scarce, so book one early. Hair sheep breeds skip the shearing but still need care.
Start small and learn
A few animals bought from a reputable seller, with health history known, beat a big first purchase. Quarantine them, watch them, and learn before you grow. Many farms find a mixed flock of sheep and goats fits their land best. And fair warning: whichever you pick, someone in the family will name them all.
