How do I compare cash and futures?
Understanding the gap between the two
KANSAS CITY, Missouri — Cash and futures are two different prices for the same commodity. Cash is what a buyer will pay you for grain or livestock delivered at a particular place and time. Futures is the price on an exchange for a standardized contract to deliver at a future month. To compare them, you subtract. The difference between the cash price and a futures price is the basis, and watching that gap is how you decide whether to sell for cash, store, or lock in a price another way. No current prices appear here, but you'll see how to compare and where the numbers live.
Match the month first
The most common mistake is comparing a cash bid to the wrong futures month. A cash bid for delivery now is normally compared to the nearby futures contract, while a bid for later delivery is compared to a later contract. Ask the buyer which futures month the bid is based on. Then compare apples to apples. If you're looking at a deferred delivery bid, it should be tied to the contract month closest to that delivery window.
A made-up example for the math
Here's pure arithmetic with round numbers. Say the futures contract for your month is X. Your elevator bids X minus 30 cents. The basis is minus 30 cents. If later in the season the bid is X minus 10 cents, the basis has strengthened by 20 cents, even if X itself hasn't moved. This is why a farmer who stores grain can gain from basis improvement, and also why a farmer who locks the futures price without locking basis can still be surprised. Both pieces move on their own schedules.
What the spread between months tells you
Futures contracts for different months trade at different prices. When later months trade above nearby ones, the market is paying for storage, often called a carry. When nearby months trade above later ones, it's called an inverse, and it signals the market wants grain now. You can see the spreads on any futures quote board. University economists at farmdoc daily and Iowa State's Ag Decision Maker write about how carry compares to storage costs, which is what you actually need to know.
Count your storage and costs
Storing grain to sell later costs money: interest on the grain value, shrink, handling, insurance, and any commercial storage fee. If the carry in the market plus expected basis improvement is bigger than your storage cost, storing may pay. If not, selling at harvest and moving on is fine. Do the math for your own bins. Your numbers aren't the neighbor's numbers. Extension offices and the AgMRC site offer tools and publications on marketing and storage analysis.
Where to find the numbers
- Futures prices: the exchange's own quote pages, your broker's platform, or farm news sites. Many show delayed quotes for free.
- Cash bids: your elevator, or aggregated bid services.
- Regional price reports: USDA AMS Market News.
- Historical basis: extension publications and your own records.
Keep a simple spreadsheet with the date, the cash bid, the futures month and the basis. It takes two minutes. Within a year, you'll know your local patterns better than any national chart does.
Cash against futures for livestock
The same logic applies to cattle and hogs, with some twists. Livestock futures settle in different ways than grain, and your cash price depends on weight, grade and the buyer's program. Basis for cattle is the cash price minus the nearby futures, and it can swing with packer demand, seasonal supply and quality. If you sell on a grid, your final price is the base plus premiums and discounts, so the futures comparison is only the starting point. Ask your buyer or auction how they price, and check regional cash reports at USDA AMS Market News. University beef and livestock economists often publish basis histories, and the University of Nebraska beef site is one place to look. As always, use history as a guide to normal ranges, not a promise of what comes next.
Futures can look like another language, but it's a short vocabulary. Cash is what you get, futures is the benchmark, and basis is the gap. Once you've got that, the rest is arithmetic and patience.
