How do I compare drying charges?
Comparing grain drying costs fairly
CHAMPAIGN, Illinois — Comparing drying charges between elevators takes more than looking at the per-point number. The charge per point of moisture is only one piece. Shrink, handling, discounts and the moisture you're actually delivering all change what you really pay. This article lays out a way to compare quotes so you aren't fooled by a low-looking rate. I won't give any actual charge, since elevators set their own and they change.
Start with the basics
Drying charges are usually quoted as a cost per bushel for each point of moisture removed above the base moisture, such as the standard moisture for the crop. If corn comes in wetter than the base, the elevator dries it down and charges accordingly. A second charge, called shrink, accounts for the weight lost when water is removed. These two together, plus any handling fee, make up the bill.
Understand shrink
Water leaves, so the bushels you're paid for are fewer than the bushels you delivered. The physical shrink for corn is a bit more than one percent per point of moisture, and elevators usually apply a shrink factor that's higher, to cover handling loss. Ask each elevator which shrink factor it uses. Two elevators with the same per-point rate and different shrink factors aren't offering the same deal.
Here's the arithmetic, using moisture points and a shrink factor so you can plug in the real numbers:
- Subtract the base moisture from your delivered moisture to get points to remove.
- Multiply points by the elevator's drying charge per point per bushel.
- Multiply points by the shrink factor to get percent shrink.
- Apply that percent to the bushels delivered, and value the lost bushels at the grain price.
- Add handling or other fees.
That total, divided by bushels delivered, is your per-bushel drying cost.
Compare more than rate and shrink
Ask about:
- Minimum charges and whether there's a charge when moisture is just barely over base
- Moisture tests, including the meter used and how often it's checked
- Rounding rules, such as whether a half point counts as a full point
- Discounts for damage or test weight, which are separate from drying
- Wait times, since trucks standing in line cost you money
- Payment terms, because holding payment is a cost
A meter that reads a little high can cost you real bushels. Ask whether the elevator's meters are inspected and how disputes are handled.
Compare to drying on the farm
If you have a bin dryer or are thinking of one, add up fuel or electricity, labor, repairs, depreciation, interest and shrink. Purdue extension and Iowa State's Ag Decision Maker publish material on grain drying and handling costs, and farmdoc daily often covers harvest decisions. On-farm drying has its own risks: overdrying wastes money and fuel, and underdrying can spoil grain in storage.
Think about harvest moisture too
Drying cost isn't fixed. Harvesting at a moisture level where field drying has done part of the work can shrink the bill. That has to be balanced against field losses, weather risk and timeliness. Your seed dealer and extension agent can talk about hybrid drydown and local patterns. There's no rule that works every year.
A comparison worksheet
For each elevator, write down: drying rate, shrink factor, handling charge, minimum charge, moisture rounding rule, wait time and payment terms. Run a sample load at your typical moisture and at a wetter level, then compare totals. Check also whether your contract or your delivery date changes the schedule.
A final check: ask for a sample settlement. Many elevators will run a sample load through their system and show you how moisture, shrink, dockage and fees are calculated on paper. Compare that with your own calculation. If the two disagree, ask where the difference comes from. It might be rounding, a different shrink factor or a charge you didn't know about, and it's better to find out before you deliver than after.
Pick the cheapest total, not the cheapest rate. And if the numbers are close, pick the one where trucks don't sit in line, because time is on the invoice too, whether it's printed there or not.
