How do I compare local versus national prices?

Matching apples to apples

BISMARCK, North Dakota — A national price tells you what USDA or an exchange reports across a broad market. A local price tells you what your buyer will pay for your load. They almost never match, and the gap has reasons. Comparing them well means lining up the commodity, the date, the units and the delivery terms first.

Know what each number means

National or exchange prices include futures quotes, national average prices received by farmers, and national summaries in USDA reports. Local prices are what elevators, mills, sale barns and packers bid in your area. The gap between a local cash price and the nearby futures price is the basis, and for livestock or hay the gap reflects regional supply, quality and freight.

USDA's monthly Agricultural Prices report from NASS shows prices received by farmers by state and nationally, which makes it a handy middle step between a national figure and your local bid.

Step by step comparison

  1. Pick one commodity and grade. Don't compare number two corn to feed corn or a premium hay bale to a mixed one.
  2. Pick one date. Prices move daily. Write down both numbers on the same day.
  3. Match units. Bushels, hundredweight, pounds, tons and metric tons aren't interchangeable without conversion.
  4. Match delivery terms. FOB the farm, delivered to a terminal and picked up at the plant are different prices.
  5. Match the marketing period. Harvest delivery, spot and deferred bids differ.
  6. Calculate the spread. Subtract one from the other and record the result.

Where to get the comparison data

Local figures come from your buyers' bids, sale reports and regional summaries on AMS Market News. National benchmarks come from futures quotes, WASDE season-average price projections and NASS Agricultural Prices data. ERS data products provide historical series if you want to chart prices over time.

Why the gap exists

Freight is a big part, since distance to the nearest terminal, river or export facility sets a local discount or premium. Local supply and demand matter too. A big local crop pushes bids down; a nearby processor can pull them up. Quality differences, storage costs and buyer margins add to it. Then there's competition: more buyers in reach usually means tighter spreads.

Is the gap normal?

To decide whether your local spread is out of line, you need history. Keep your own log of local bids and the matching futures price or national figure for a season. Iowa State's Ag Decision Maker and farmdoc daily explain basis tracking and offer examples of seasonal patterns you can compare to your records. Seasonal patterns often show weaker local prices at harvest, but check your own data before assuming it holds in your area.

What to do with the answer

If your local price is consistently below a reasonable freight-adjusted alternative, look at other markets. Price a haul to a farther buyer, including trucking, shrink and time. Ask your current buyer why the bid is where it is. Sometimes there's a good reason, like limited storage space at the plant, and sometimes nobody's ever asked.

If you sell livestock, compare sale barn results to the USDA market reports for your region, and note the weight, grade and class. For hay, match the test results to the type of hay in the report.

Transportation deserves a line of its own. Truck costs vary with distance, fuel and the time of year, and elevators often quote prices that already include a freight discount to a terminal. If you're comparing a farther market, ask the buyer for a delivered price and then subtract your own hauling cost per bushel or per hundredweight. Add the cost of a day lost to a longer trip, and include shrink if you're moving livestock. A comparison that leaves out freight will often point you the wrong way.

Don't chase every cent

A farther market that pays a few cents more may lose that gain to fuel and time. Do the full math, include discounts and payment terms and then decide. A national price is a fine compass, but it's not the check you'll deposit.