How do I find farmland sale comparables?

Building a comp sheet

WICHITA, Kansas — Farmland sale comparables, usually shortened to comps, are recent sales of similar land used to estimate what a parcel is worth. Finding good ones takes some legwork, but the records are mostly public and the method is the same one appraisers use.

A good comp is similar in location, soils, size, use and sale conditions, and it sold recently enough to reflect today's market.

Where to find the sales

Start with the county. The recorder, assessor or register of deeds keeps deed transfers, and some counties post them online. Whether the sale price shows up depends on state law, so check what your county provides. Where prices aren't public, ask a broker or appraiser. Real estate brokers, auction companies and land professionals often keep their own sales data. Lenders and appraisers see many sales and may share general market information. The Farm Credit system lenders and agricultural banks track land markets as part of their business, so ask your lender what they're seeing.

Local newspapers, auction company websites and state realtor groups may also post sales. Don't forget informal sources, like neighbors and the co-op, though treat hearsay as a lead to verify, not a data point.

Gather the details for each comp

For every sale, record these items.

  1. Location, distance from your parcel and road access.
  2. Acres, and how many are tillable, pasture, timber or waste.
  3. Soil types and productivity ratings. The Web Soil Survey provides soil maps and data for most counties.
  4. Drainage, tile, irrigation rights, fencing, buildings and water sources.
  5. Sale price per acre, sale type (auction, private treaty, family transfer) and terms.
  6. Lease status, possession date and any easements or mineral rights.
  7. Interest rate and crop conditions around the time, as context.

Arm's-length sales between unrelated parties are the most useful. Family transfers and forced sales often don't reflect market value.

Adjust for differences

No two parcels match. Appraisers adjust the price per acre of each comp for differences. If a comp has better soils, the adjusted price for your parcel comes down. If your land has tile and the comp doesn't, adjust up. Keep your adjustments reasonable and written down, so you can explain them. Beyond that, weigh the closest, most recent, most similar sales most heavily.

Cross-check with surveys

Compare your comp range with published surveys. The National Agricultural Statistics Service publishes annual land values by state, and the Economic Research Service offers farmland value data and background. University and Federal Reserve surveys are other sources, and farmdoc daily discusses land value trends. If your comps are far from the survey numbers, work out why: maybe your area has better soils than the state average, or maybe your comps are outliers.

When to hire a professional

A comp sheet helps you negotiate and plan, but it isn't an appraisal. If you're buying with a loan, settling an estate, dividing property or dealing with taxes, hire a qualified appraiser familiar with agricultural land. The IRS Publication 225 covers some tax topics related to farm property, and a tax advisor can tell you when a formal appraisal is needed.

A quick routine

Make a spreadsheet with a row per sale and columns for the items above. Update it as new sales appear. Look at it before any land decision. Over time you'll see your market clearly, including which soils and which sizes of tract draw the most interest.

Keep notes on the story behind each sale, since the number alone can hide the reason. A tract that sold quickly to a neighbor, a sale forced by an estate, or a parcel with a poor access road each tells a different story. Those notes help you decide which comps deserve weight and which are best ignored when you're setting a price.

The current numbers in your county are in the sales records and in the heads of local brokers and appraisers. Go get them, and write down the ones that surprise you. Those are the sales that tell you where the market is moving, and they're also the ones the neighbors will talk about at the cafe.