How do I track horse sale prices?
Finding real horse sale results
LEXINGTON, Kentucky — Horse prices are the least standardized prices in agriculture. There's no national daily report, no futures market and no single grade system. A foal, a working ranch horse and a proven performance mare can all be "horses" and share nothing but the species. As far as I know, USDA doesn't publish a regular national horse price report, so confirm that before you go looking. What you can do is track actual sale results from the places where horses sell. This article covers where to look and what to compare.
Auction company results
Many horse sales publish catalogs and results afterward. Thoroughbred sales companies such as Keeneland and Fasig-Tipton, along with many quarter horse, draft horse and performance horse sales, post results on their websites. Look for hammer prices (what the horse sold for), not asking prices. Results often show the sire, dam, age, sex and sometimes the buyer type.
Livestock auctions that include horses may post sale sheets or a report. If you're after riding horses, ranch horses or working animals, local and regional sales are often the best indicator for your area.
Breed registries and associations
Breed associations sometimes publish sale summaries, especially for high-profile sales and futurities. Search for your breed's association and look at the events, sales and news sections. Some register sale results or maintain a sale reports page. Don't expect a tidy table. You may have to read through catalogs and result lists and pull your own numbers.
What makes one horse worth more than another
When comparing, match these factors:
- Age and sex, since stallions, mares, geldings and weanlings sell in different brackets
- Breeding and pedigree, if the discipline values it
- Training and record, including show or race results, certified ranch work or years under saddle
- Health and soundness, often documented through a veterinary exam
- Temperament, which matters enormously and is hard to write down
- Location and venue, because the same horse can bring different prices in different regions and at different kinds of sales
A sale price at a high-end consignment auction doesn't tell you what a backyard gelding is worth at a local sale.
Build your own records
Because no single report covers it, keep your own log. Record the date, venue, horse description, price and any conditions of sale, such as vet check, sold-as-is or guarantee. Over time, you'll see how your type of horse prices in your market. A notebook or spreadsheet is enough.
If you're also looking at costs, the Iowa State Ag Decision Maker site has budgeting tools that can be adapted for livestock enterprises, and eXtension has horse care and management resources. Costs for feed, hay, farrier, vet and boarding add up quickly, and they should be part of any decision.
Tax and legal notes
Horse sales can be treated as farm income if you're in the business of breeding, raising or training them, or as something else if you're not. The rules depend on your situation. The IRS Publication 225, the Farmer's Tax Guide, explains the treatment of livestock sales, including horses used for certain purposes. A hobby and a business are treated differently, so talk to a tax preparer who understands agriculture.
Also check your state's rules on sales, brand inspection and transport, since requirements vary. Get the paperwork in order: bill of sale, registration papers, health certificate and Coggins test documentation when required.
Remember too that sale prices for horses often include things the price doesn't show, such as a vet check, a short-term trial or a seller's guarantee. Two horses that sold for the same hammer price may have been very different deals once those terms are counted. When you record a result, note the terms, and if you're the seller, put the terms in writing before the sale so there's no argument afterward about what was promised.
Tracking horse prices takes more work than tracking corn. The upside is that you'll understand your corner of the market in a way no national report could give you.
