How do I track rail grain shipments?

Carloads, shuttle trains and service data

FARGO, North Dakota — If your grain moves by rail, or your elevator's bid depends on rail service, you'll want to track how well the railroads are performing and what shipping capacity costs. Public data exist, and some of them are free. This article explains what to look for in each source, how to interpret terms like shuttle train and secondary market, and how to put the data to use in your marketing. It doesn't quote current rail rates or service levels, since both change often, and you should read them at the source.

Weekly carloads and rail traffic

The Association of American Railroads publishes weekly rail traffic data, including grain carloads, and trade press often summarizes it. The USDA's Grain Transportation Report, published weekly by AMS, compiles information on rail grain traffic, rail rates for shuttle and unit trains, and rail service notes. It also includes the number of grain cars loaded in some summaries. Use these to see whether volume is above or below the same week in prior years, and whether the number reflects a change in demand or a service problem.

Understand shuttle trains and the secondary market

A shuttle train is a dedicated train of a set number of cars that cycles between a loading elevator and a destination, usually a port or large processor. Railroads sell the right to ship a train in advance through certificates, and a secondary market trades those certificates between shippers. When the bids for secondary certificates are high, it generally signals that rail capacity is tight, and when they're low or negative, capacity is easier to get. The AMS report publishes secondary market bid and offer information. That tells you what shippers are paying in addition to the base tariff rate.

Service metrics and reliability

Rail service isn't only about price. Transit times, velocity, dwell and the number of cars delayed all affect how well grain moves. The Surface Transportation Board collects and posts service data from the largest railroads, and the railroads themselves publish service metrics on their websites. These measures help you tell whether a shortfall in shipments is about slow service or low demand. Weather, equipment shortages, labor and maintenance work can all cause disruptions, and notices usually appear in railroad service advisories.

How rail affects your bid

Rail costs influence the basis your elevator can offer. An elevator that loads shuttle trains has to price in tariff rates, secondary market costs and the risk of delays. When rail is tight, the elevator may widen basis or limit new purchases, and when it eases, bids can improve. Ask your elevator whether they're on a shuttle loading point or truck grain to a river terminal, and how rail conditions affect their bid. Try to find out how often they've had delivery periods where they stopped taking grain, since that tells you about reliability.

Reading the terms on a contract

If you deliver on a shuttle loading contract, read the delivery period, the grade and quality terms, and what happens if the elevator can't take grain because of a service disruption. Some contracts allow deferred delivery or price adjustments, and others don't. Ask who pays storage if your grain is held on the farm while the elevator waits for cars, and what the penalty is for late delivery on either side. Having those answers before harvest is far better than hunting for them in a line of trucks.

A tracking routine

farmdoc daily and extension economists periodically explain how rail costs affect basis, and eXtension and state extension programs may have regional resources. If you've got a problem with rail service on your own shipments, state grain shipper associations and the Surface Transportation Board's consumer assistance functions exist for that purpose, so ask your cooperative or state commodity group what applies.