What is the outlook for cattle price insurance?

Reading availability and costs without a crystal ball

WICHITA, Kansas — No one can honestly predict what cattle price insurance will cost or pay in a coming season, and this article won't try. What it can do is explain what drives the cost and payoff, how the products are set up, and where to check what's on offer today.

Cattle price insurance covers a drop in an index price over a set period. The premium reflects how much the market is expected to move, how far below current levels you want protection, and how long the coverage lasts. Those pieces shift as markets shift.

What counts as cattle price insurance

The main federally backed tool for cattle price protection is Livestock Risk Protection, offered through RMA. It covers certain classes such as feeder and fed cattle, with coverage tied to futures-based or index prices. Other margin-style products have been offered for cattle as well, and availability can change. Check the current list at rma.usda.gov and with an authorized agent.

What moves premiums

Because premium quotes can differ day to day, a quote you got last week might not hold. Ask your agent how long a quote is good for.

Where to see how markets have behaved

The AMS Market News site publishes cattle auction, direct and boxed beef reports that show how prices and volumes have moved. NASS publishes cattle inventory and cattle on feed data, which describe supply, and ERS publishes livestock and meat outlook reports with analysis. Those are the places to see official commentary on what analysts think about the coming months. Read them yourself and notice where the language is hedged, because it usually is.

Extension commentary

Beef economists at land-grant universities write regularly about price risk and insurance. See Nebraska's beef site, K-State Research and Extension, and farmdoc daily. They often compare insurance with forward contracts and futures hedges, and describe tradeoffs without telling you what to do.

Decide with your own numbers

  1. Work out your breakeven per head or per hundredweight, including feed, interest and death loss.
  2. Decide the lowest price you can live with.
  3. Get quotes at several coverage levels.
  4. Compare the premium to the loss you're trying to avoid.
  5. Talk it through with your lender, since some lenders like to see price protection.

Questions for your lender and your agent

Lenders sometimes treat price protection as a plus, but they differ, so ask. What coverage level would you like to see on the cattle we're financing? Would you adjust the line if we carried protection? Then ask your agent practical questions. Does the product cover my weight class and my sale timing? What do I do if I sell early, or hold animals longer than planned? How is the premium billed? Write down the answers. If you hear different things from two people, ask for the answer in writing from the one who'll be responsible for it.

Finally, keep a calendar of coverage end dates and sale plans together. A policy that expires a week before you ship does little for you, and an end date after your sale can leave you holding protection on cattle you no longer own.

Remember basis

The insured price is tied to an index, and what you get at your local barn differs by basis, quality and timing. Look at your own sale records to see how big that gap has been.

Cattle insurance is a way to put a floor under the downside you can't afford, and it's priced accordingly. If someone offers an outlook that sounds certain, ask for their record. The cattle market has humbled people with better charts than yours or mine.