Which analysts cover grain markets best?

How to judge coverage instead of picking a winner

OMAHA, Nebraska — There isn't an honest answer that names one best grain analyst, because "best" depends on what you need: daily price commentary, long-term fundamentals, marketing plans or plain-language education. What you can do is judge any analyst by a short list of tests, and build a reading list that mixes public sources with a few voices you've tested yourself.

Here's how to do it without paying for anything until you know what you're buying.

Start with the primary data

Before any opinion, read the facts. NASS publishes crop progress, stocks and acreage data. ERS publishes outlooks and farm economy analysis. AMS Market News publishes cash prices, basis and movement data for many locations. If you know these reports, you can tell when an analyst is describing them accurately and when they're spinning them.

University economists

Land-grant economists explain markets in public, with no product to sell you. Farmdoc daily from the University of Illinois, the Iowa State Ag Decision Maker and its Center for Agricultural Law and Taxation, AgMRC, and other state extension programs publish analysis and tools. They tend to stress concepts and tradeoffs rather than price calls, which is useful if you want to make your own decisions.

Commercial analysts and broadcasters

Private analysts, brokerages, newsletters and farm broadcasters also provide market commentary. Some are very good at explaining the day's action. Judge them on the same tests you'd use for anyone:

Test them yourself

Pick two or three analysts and keep a simple log for a season. Write down each forecast or recommendation with the date, and mark later whether it turned out right, wrong or unclear. Include the ones you disagreed with. This costs nothing, and it will teach you more about who to trust than any ranking.

Look for fit

A grain analyst who's great at global trade flows may not know anything about local basis. An analyst with a strong view on futures may not help with storage decisions. Match the source to your question. For basis and local conditions, your elevator and your extension office may be the better source.

Beware of certainty

Markets move on information that nobody has yet. An analyst who sounds certain about direction is either lucky or selling something. Treat strong claims with the same caution you'd give a salesman at the fair. A good analyst gives you scenarios, odds and what would change their mind.

Matching analysts to your decisions

Consider what decision you're facing before you pick who to read. If you're deciding when to sell stored grain, you want someone who covers basis, carry and storage economics. If you're picking crop mix, you want longer-run economic analysis. If you want to understand a report that came out an hour ago, you want a fast, clear explainer. No one does all three equally well. Keep a note by each source of what it's good for. That keeps you from asking a news commentator for budgeting advice or an economist for tomorrow's trade call, and it makes your reading time count.

If you hear a name often in the coffee shop, that's a reason to check the record, not a reason to trust it. Popularity and accuracy are different things, and the market has never graded on a curve.

Build a short reading list

  1. One or two public sources for data and education.
  2. One commentary source you've tested.
  3. Your local buyer for basis and delivery information.
  4. A written marketing plan to keep you from reacting to every headline.

Read widely, keep score, and let results decide who stays on the list. The Iowa PBS Market to Market program is another public source worth a look for weekly market discussion.