Which sources cover water rights values?
Where to look before you price a right
BOISE, Idaho — There is no single national report that lists what water rights are worth. Values get set one sale at a time, ditch by ditch and district by district, which means you piece the number together from several places. The good news is that most of those places are public, and a few hours of digging beats a handshake guess every time.
Water rights are property under state law, and the rules differ a lot between states. A right that sells for a lot in one basin may be nearly worthless in the next because of priority date, location, or whether it can legally be moved. Start with the sources below, then confirm everything with a water attorney or your state water agency.
Start with your state water agency
Every western state has an office that records water rights, usually called the state engineer, the department of water resources, or something close. That office holds the right's priority date, quantity, place of use, and any history of transfers. You can't price a right until you know what it actually legally allows. Ask for the permit, license or decree number, and look at whether the right has been used recently, since many states have forfeiture or abandonment rules for rights that sit idle.
County records and sale prices
Deeds and transfer filings at the county recorder or assessor's office often show what changed hands. Some states require water transfers to be filed with the state agency, and those filings sometimes list consideration. Not every sale shows a price, so treat what you find as a sample, not a full market.
USDA data that touches irrigated land
The NASS website publishes land values reports that separate irrigated cropland from non-irrigated cropland and pasture. The gap between those categories is a rough hint at what irrigation access adds to land, though it isn't a clean water price. NASS also runs an irrigation survey on a multi-year cycle that covers acres, water sources and expenses. For background on how irrigation fits into farm economics, the ERS farm economy pages are a decent starting point.
Appraisers, brokers and water market analysts
Rural appraisers who work in your area often track water sales because they need them for land appraisals. Some regions also have brokers and research firms that follow water leases and sales in basins where trading is active. Ask any source how they collect data, how many transactions are behind a figure, and whether the sales are comparable to your situation. Lease rates and sale prices are different things, and so are rights tied to land versus rights sold separately.
Extension and university work
Land-grant universities regularly publish studies on water markets, irrigation economics and land values in their states. Searching your state's extension site, or starting at extension.org, usually turns up local papers that explain how values moved and why. Those papers are better at explaining the drivers than at giving you today's number, so read them for method.
Questions worth asking before you trust a number
- What is the priority date, and how does it rank in dry years?
- Is the right tied to land, or can it be sold or leased separately?
- Has it been used within the period the state requires?
- Does the delivery system, such as a ditch company or irrigation district, charge assessments on top?
- Is the sale or lease price you found a cash deal, a package with land, or a family transfer?
Assessments and shares matter more than people expect. A share in a ditch company may come with annual costs and rules that change what the share is worth to you.
A water right worth a certain amount on paper is only worth that if you can legally and physically deliver the water to your ground. Check that, then go shopping for comparable sales. If a number sounds too good to be true on a hot dry day, remember that water has a way of making everyone an optimist right up until the ditch runs short.
